Monday, September 29, 2008

Week 6: Discussion 1

Is it possible to perceive others without in some way judging or categorizing them? If so, how? If not, how can we make the judgments we make more fair?

As human being we cannot help judging the people around us. We look at things and people and interpret them. Based off what we see and interpret we make assumptions and begin passing judgment and categorizing people.

Photobucket

Look at the picture above. Many people would look at this picture and assume the two men in baggy jeans and sweatshirts are jobless and unmotivated, possibly drug dealers or users and most likely untrustworthy. The faces of the men are not even shown, however, many people would still pass this judgment on these people. Society gives us stereotypes that we live by and we cannot help be interpret certain images in a particular way.

Just the other day I was talking to someone in my class. It was only the second time I have ever talked to him. He said that he could tell the people who are from San Jose apart from the people who are not. Living in San Jose my whole life, I asked what he thought of me. He said, "You are definitely not from San Jose." When I asked why he said, I can tell by the way you talk. I admitted that I was from San Jose and he was in total disbelief. He then asked, "Were you really sheltered growing up, or do you spend a lot of time with your family?" as if this would in someway explain my non-San Joseian essence. I was not sheltered as a child, nor do I spend a large amount of time with my family. This just goes to show you cannot judge a book by its cover and you cannot judge a San Jose natives by the way they talk.

The only way we can make our judgments more fair is to realize that they are only judgments. We must take into consideration we are making unfair judgments and then put them aside until we really get to know a person. We must say to ourselves, "Although I see this person in a certain way, they are not really this way." Once we get to know a person then we can make our true judgments on them because we know who they really are, not just what we thought they were.

Saturday, September 20, 2008

Week4: Discussion 3

Pick one concept from the assigned reading that you found useful or interesting and discuss it. 

What I found most interesting about this weeks reading was the social functions of rhetoric, particularly distributing power. Trenholm explains that the knowledge of rhetoric and being able to speak publicly gives us power. Rhetoric gives us personal power. Personal power gives us the skills for personal success and career advancement. Through rhetoric we can present ourselves professionally and communicate to others why we deserve a promotion over the other candidates.  It also give us the ability to communicate effectively in our personal relationships, leading to more positive and successful relationships with friend, family and loved ones. 

Another power rhetoric gives us is psychological power. Using rhetoric we can shape the way people think. Politicians and activist use rhetoric constantly in order to gain support form the public. They speak in a way that leads people to believe in certain propositions or proposals and help the public form opinions about the world around us. 

The last power rhetoric give us is political power. Political power gives us a voice. We have the ability to give speeches and talk publicly about the things we care about. If we want to try to convince others of our views or just make them known we can do this through the power of rhetoric. The better we understand rhetoric the easier our points come across. Political power can lead to psychological power if your voice is heard and accepted. Sometimes, however, it is hard to get our voice heard. Some people are better supported in spreading their voice while others are swept under the rug. This is a reason why we should study rhetoric. If we can be persuasive, strategic and captivating  we can get people to listen to what we have to say. 

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Week 4: Discussion 2

Consider a well-known speaker, for example, the current President of the United States (or a Presidential candidate). What is this speaker’s strongest characteristics as a speaker? Is it credibility, attractiveness, power or all three? In what ways could the speaker build ethos in these areas?

When I think of the words “well-known speaker,” Barack Obama immediately comes to mind. Obama has many strong speaking characteristics. He has the charisma and speaking ability that people look for in a president. He can captivate a wide audience and appeals to people of all ages and ethnicities not only because of his political views but because he is an amazing speaker.

This all stems from the fact that Obama possesses attractiveness. The book defines attractiveness as offering “audience members an emotionally rewarding relationship,” (p. 261). This is something Obama is great at. He is close with his followers because he shares his values and beliefs with them and does it on a personal level. He motivates people to want change and helps them realize that he wants what is best for the people of the United States. He is charismatic and physically attractive which makes him likeable and seem trustworthy.

Obama’s charisma also adds to his credibility. People feel that that can trust what he says. Also his experience and openness to showing his family values and beliefs and stories adds to his credibility.

Obama could enhance his attractiveness by continuing to identify with his audience and showing that he has a genuine interest in what they want. He could improve his credibility by pointing out his past experience and how it has prepared him to be a successful leader.

Monday, September 15, 2008

Week 4: Discussion 1

Have you ever been influenced by a speaker? Think of the best speaker you ever heard. What was it about that speaker that made his or her communication memorable? Think of the worst speaker you’ve ever heard. What do you remember about his or her message?

The best speaker I have ever heard was this guy that came to my middle school to talk to the sixth grade class. I can’t remember his name but I remember the speech very well.

Sixth grade is a very hard time for most kids. You’re going to a new school and you’re starting to go through puberty; you start dealing with a whole new set of problems once you start sixth grade. It’s scary, confusing and embarrassing. The speaker came to let the students know that things are going to change, and that’s okay. He helped everyone realize that even if you feel alone, everyone else is going through the same thing. He explained the importance of helping each other, instead of making it worse for your peers.

I specifically remember him talking about when he was in sixth grade, going to his first dance. He joked about how awkward dancing was for him and how he didn’t know which dance moves were ‘girl only.’ His speech was memorable not only because he had a strong message, but also, he was extremely funny. He made uncomfortable subjects seem easier to talk about while keeping the message serious. He kept everyone entertained and interested through his delivery and stories.

The worst speaker I ever heard was a guy from my speech class a few semesters ago. It was so bad I wasn’t even sure what his speech was about. I had to evaluate his persuasive speech but it was so hard to understand his stance on the subject because he didn’t clearly state what he was talking about or what his stance was. I know he was talking about Michael Vick’s trial for the dog fights. He started off talking about how bad it was but later it sounded like he was trying to convince everyone Michael Vick shouldn’t be convicted. He brought up weird points saying, “People who do bad things don’t know they are bad because they are grown to be bad.” That is an actual quote from his speech. Also, most of the time I couldn’t hear what he was saying. Between his low voice and unclear language it was literally impossible to understand anything he wanted to say.

This speech was so bad the only message I got from it was: Don’t come to speech class unprepared.

Wednesday, September 10, 2008

Week 3: Discussion 3

Consider the pragmatic perspective. Does it make sense to think of communication as a patterned interaction? How is communication like a game? How is it different from a game?

In some situations it does make sense to think of communication as patterned interactions. For example, when you first start dating someone you learn what your partner likes, dislikes and what he or she will put up with. Through this you learn the patterns that work within the relationship and follow these patterns of interaction to continue a healthy relationship.

My friend Briana often follows communication pattern in her relationship with her boyfriend to predict the outcome of a situation. She is most always right, however, she does little to change the pattern even when she knows the outcome will be negative. Instead of changing her reaction to what her boyfriend says to her, she repeats conversations she has had in the past, thus resulting in the same bad outcome. I often tell her that she should do something different such as change how she talks to him in certain situations or change her wording in order to change his reaction so that the conversation can turn into something more positive and have a better outcome than other previous, similar situations.

Communication is like a game in many ways. Each person takes turns to talk, just as in a game when players take turn to move. When a player moves, it usually affects what another player. When someone says something to you, you must react to that, just as a player must react to their opponent’s move.

Sometimes people play games in communication that are more obvious. When a person wants to get information out of someone they use different strategies, like in a game of poker. The game is to get you opponent to give up some information you want to know. Your opponent wants to try to make sure you do not get any of the information. For example, say I wanted to figure out what my boyfriend bought me for my birthday. I would strategically ask a series of question until he slipped some information that would give me a clue to what the gift is. He’s challenge is to make sure he doesn’t slip and say something that could give away and give me a clue to what it is he got me.

There is also the communication of “getting what you want,” also known as manipulation. The game is to talk your opponent into doing what you want to do apposed to what he wants to do. This could be done by showing only the downsides of what he wants to do and playing up the good things about what you want to do. The use of guilt or stubbornness can usually get an opponent to give in.

I don’t think that communication always has to be a game. I believe sometimes people just get together and talk and it can go anywhere. It doesn’t always follow a pattern or have some goal or end people are trying to reach. If you get together with a friend and sit down to catch up there is no pattern or game to that. You just talk together and that’s it. Yes, you could look deeper into it and say that together you and your friend are reacting to each other’s stories and creating a pattern through these stories and reaction. I feel that this is stretching the idea of communication patterns. Anything could be called a pattern if you stretch the idea thin enough.

Monday, September 8, 2008

Week 3: Discussion 2

Consider the social constructionist perspective. How do we “build worlds” through communication? Think of some ideas we talk about in our culture that may not exist in other cultures. How do these concepts contribute to our happiness or success (or the lack of these) in our culture?

Through communication, culture is built. We communicate with the people around us and make rules, rituals and define what is normal and what is not. This builds walls between other cultures or others who communicate differently. Through communication we create a living situation, a life style, a whole world that we grow accustom to. When we are introduced to something different, to new rules, new rituals, new forms of communication, it feels completely foreign, as if from another world.

Often, ideas do not translate over to different cultures. Humor is a prime example. Humor, much of the time, is based off a culture’s social aspects. If you do not understand another’s culture, it is hard to understand what the jokes are referring to. Also cultures have their own style of delivery in comedy. For example in Germany, most comedy is compiled if skits and are acted out by the comedians. To many German immigrants (such as my boss) American comedy does not make any sense. Although my boss (who is from German) has been here long enough to understand the American culture and understand the jokes, he thinks it is absurd to have a person standing in front of an audience telling a long string of jokes.

Ideas are often unique to a culture, just as comedy is. America for example is a democracy. Politics are apart of our daily lives usually. We must vote on new policies, new laws, new politicians, and new leaders. In many cultures, the people are not allowed to vote. The have no voice in their society. In many countries this is a huge problem because people are mistreated and have no say against their government. As Americans, we are lucky to be able to communicate what we want as individuals and as a community. We have the opportunity to change the things we disagree with and improve the things we don’t like. Americans sometimes take this for granted but for the most part I believe we are very prideful to have the freedom to vote and impact our government.

Sunday, September 7, 2008

Week 3: Discussion 1

Pick one concept from the assigned reading that you found useful or interesting and discuss it.

The concept I found most interesting was the Psychological Model. According our class book, the Psychological Model is a psychological communication process two or more people exchange meaning through the transmission and reception of communication stimuli.

In this model one sender/receiver encodes an idea he has by translating it in a message he thinks his friend will understand. The message travels along a channel (whether it be email, talking, text, ect) to its destination, his friend. Once his friend decodes the message, the friend gives the sender/receiver feedback.

The book points out that ‘noise’ affect the message before it reached its destination. This can cause confusion and/or misinterpretation of the message. The book gives an example of how the inability to hear a professor’s lecture makes it impossible for some students to decode the message the professor has sent. It also talks about how the physically appearance of the professor distracts the students and acts as another form of noise. I found this interesting because I never thought of silent objects as being ‘noise.’ I can understand however, because in one of my classes a certain advertising teacher would wear crazy outfits that were completely distracting and a hot topic of discussion among her students. Instead of listening to her lecture many people would pass notes about how many different prints of animals she was wearing.

Not only can noise negatively effect communication, so can misinterpretation of a message. The intended interpretation of a message is critical for successful communication. For example, Adam sends a message to Betty asking, “Are you going to school?” What Adam is trying to ask is if Betty is physically going to school that day. Betty interprets the message differently. She thinks he means, “Are you attending school?” She responds, “Yes, I go to San Jose State.” Obviously this conversation was unsuccessful (so far) because the feedback Betty gave Adam was not the information he wanted. In order to get the answer he is looking for, Adam would have to encode a new message that is more specific so that Betty will be able to interpret in the way Adam intends it to be interpreted.