Do you believe in the rationality, perfectibility and mutability premises? What social institutions and practices are based on these beliefs?
I do believe in the rationality premise. I think that the average person can use rationality to make quality decisions. In America we base our government round the idea that people can be trusted to make the best decision possible. I think that if a person has a clear and open mind that can make the best decisions. If these qualities are not present then closed mindedness will inhibit a good decision.
I disagree with the perfectibility premise. I think people are all born good and natural. I think that events and the surrounding we are submersed in can influence us to become sinful but we are not born that way. We choose to be sinful or we choose to make good decisions. Christianity believes that people are born into a sinful world and only by asking for forgiveness can they be freed from their sins. I do not agree with this way of thinking. I think that it is just a way of controlling people by scaring them into thinking they must prove themselves to rid themselves of sin that does not really exist.
I do agree with the mutability premise. I think that the environment around us influences who we become and how we can. I do believe however we still have some control over our decision and our actions but we are heavily influence by our surroundings. If you group up in a bad neighborhood where you are taught that stealing has no consequences then you are likely to believe this and steal. If you teach people that stealing is wrong and put them in a better environment then they will understand and learn how to make better decisions.
Wednesday, October 22, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
I totally understand where your coming from with your idea about the rationality premise. At first I agreed with the premise, and then I started thinking about our government and our legal system. I really do believe that we are lucky to live in such a fair country, but on the other hand, I do feel like many mistakes are made in such institutions. There are so many people who commit crimes and get away with it because lawyers are trained to come off as truthful, when in reality they may be totally lying. As humans, we tend to believe that some people are not capable of doing such horrible things because they don’t fit the role of a bad guy. Lawyers manipulate the truth in a way which our logic may have a hard time comprehending. The same situation is seen in our government. Our logic may tell us that all signs point to a candidate being truthful, but later we find out that they were lying. As much as I wish that we were able to fully understand truth by using our logic, I believe our logic can only go so far when up against lies.
Post a Comment